Tuesday, September 24, 2019
Formula For Peace: Iran-Saudi-US, Taliban-US, India-Pakistan
Iran-Saudi-US
Situation: War is not an option. An all-out attack by the US on Iran and an all-out counter-attack is unthinkable. For one, there would be a global Depression. It would be like the global economy had a heart attack. A seizure. Even when you are not talking, you are essentially "talking," you are signaling.
Interesting: The Saudis, the Iranians and the Americans all are on excellent terms with both Imran Khan and Narendra Modi. Both Modi and Imran should come together and help out Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the US.
Solution: Go back to the Obama nuclear deal and while you are at it, negotiate on all other outstanding matters. Give full engagement to Iran as a conclusion step. Maximum trade, maximum tourism.
Rationale: If you want democracy in Iran, you want to engage to the maximum. Trade also prevents war. If the Chinese and American supply chains were not such a spaghetti, we would already have seen a US-China hot war by now.
Taliban-US
Situation: The Taliban and the Afghan government refuse to talk to each other, but both are willing to talk to Imran Khan.
Interesting: Both the Afghan government and the Taliban are eager to talk to Imran Khan. The Indian government is on good terms with the Afghan government.
Solution: Integrate the Afghan Army and the Taliban to create one unified army, like happened with the Maoists of Nepal and the Nepal Army in the mid 2000s.
Bottomline: The Taliban must agree to become a political party and contest elections in Afghanistan.
India-Pakistan
Situation: Indian Kashmir is under curfew for more than 50 days running now.
Interesting: Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the US are all on excellent terms with both Imran Khan and Narendra Modi.
Solution: Let Pakistan and India recognize the Line Of Control as the final border between the two countries and compete with each other to install democracy and human rights in both Kashmirs. This formula of recognizing the LOC as the final border is also the solution to the India-China border dispute. They have the longest disputed border in the world.
Bottomline: The curfew in Kashmir must be lifted immediately.
Formula For Peace: Iran-Saudi-US, Taliban-US, India-Pakistan https://t.co/WYH2zyif7Y @ImranKhanPTI @narendramodi @realDonaldTrump @IsraeliPM @USUN @StateDept #iran #SaudiArabia #Taliban #Afghanistan #KashmirStillUnderCurfew #india #pakistan #ImranKhanForPeace #ModiInUSA— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 24, 2019
Obama, Trump And Greta
Here is when Greta met a real leader & President! “Our future will be shaped by the next generation & Greta isn't waiting to get started. At 16, Greta Thunberg is a leading voice in the fight to save our planet. #GretaThunbergOutdidTrump #GretaThurnberg pic.twitter.com/A7CChCgobd
— Matt Leeds (@Mleeds2048) September 24, 2019
Can't find it just now, but a clever tweep captioned earlier: "Clarice Starling realises Jame Gumb is 'Buffalo Bill'." I can see it. #HowDareYou #ClimateEmergency #GretaThunberg #GretaThunbergOutdidTrump #Greta4NobelPrize https://t.co/4tPR1G67jC
— 💧🌏🏳️🌈Jenny Frecklington-Jones; #HomeToBilo (@Triplejay58) September 24, 2019
Ooh, #GretaThunbergOutdidTrump by just staring at him at the @UN in #NewYorkCity because @realDonaldTrump is currently under investigation over the #MuellerReport. Indeed not. https://t.co/phv4oUDd3d
— Terrence L. Blackwell (@TBlackwe85) September 23, 2019
This beautiful girl is inspirational and she is the future. #teamgreta #GretaThurnberg #Greta #GretaThunbergOutdidTrump https://t.co/ZnfzQgrwOD
— Robin Carus (@robincarus) September 23, 2019
Trump mocks teenage climate activist Greta Thunberg By late Tuesday morning, she had updated her Twitter bio to read: "A very happy young girl looking forward to a bright and wonderful future." ....... "Parents in America and around the world: he went after a 16 year old girl yesterday. @realDonaldTrump unfit to serve," Scaramucci tweeted on Tuesday. ...... crossed paths with Trump at the UN General Assembly. Video captured her staring down the US President. ...... The young Swede has been open about her diagnosis of Asperger's, calling it a "superpower" that helps her activism. ....... "My diagnosis has definitely helped me keep this focus. When you are interested about something you just continue to read about it and you get super focused"
Make America GRETA again!#GretaThunbergOutdidTrump#GretaThunberg https://t.co/LL3lk4sCgs
— Francesco Sicilia (@frasicilia) September 24, 2019
@realDonaldTrump
— Connie B (@conlovesmusic) September 24, 2019
THIS should have kept the moron from being elected..
not to mention his 50 years of corruption and lies.#GretaThunbergOutdidTrump #GretaThurnberg #LauraIngraham #MichaelKnowles #BeBest #TrumpIsADisgrace https://t.co/Q6OecGdItV
Obama, Trump And Greta https://t.co/TYoMOF89lr #GretaThunbergOutdidTrump #GretaThurnberg #Greta #GretaTheGreat #ClimateAction #ClimateStrikedc #ClimateActionNow #DonaldTrump #gretathumberg #GlobalHeating
— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 24, 2019
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi planned to sit down with the six lawmakers leading committees investigating Trump as previously undecided Dems — including several moderates from swing districts — signaled new support for impeachment.https://t.co/QJ4T3biu4e
— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) September 24, 2019
Children of the Corn, Right? https://t.co/XCF86dUJRd
— Howard Bowling (@howard74) September 23, 2019
Look back. President Obama on progress around the world as he made his final address at the UN United Nations back in 2016. “It could not have happened had we not worked together” on American leadership in the world at #UNGA #UnitedNations #PresidentObama https://t.co/zm29GCtNFw
— Matt Leeds (@Mleeds2048) September 24, 2019
Monday, September 23, 2019
Imran Wants To Lift 100 Million Pakistanis Out Of Poverty
So says Imran. I think he can get it done. Not only that, I don't see anyone else on the horizon who can get it done. How will he be able to get it done? Here are my ideas.
- Peace with India. This is the most important thing. Unless India and Pakistan can figure out a way to create lasting peace, Pakistan will have it tough. And the formula for peace is that both agree that the Line Of Control will be the final border, and both will compete with each other to bring democracy and human rights to Kashmiris on both sides. Then they have to focus on trade and gradually, over time, get the troops away from their borders.
- Peace in Afghanistan. I'd say to Imran, break the rule and talk to the Taliban. There is something about this Pathan Saheb that the Pakistani Army Chief plays ball with him, and looks like the Taliban want to respectfully talk to him. Let them. The formula for peace there is like what happened in Nepal. The Maoists and the Nepal Army were at war. Peace meant the two armies got combined and became one. Incorporate the Taliban fighters into the Afghan Army even if that means a huge defense budget. Peace is worth the price.
- Peace between Iran and Saudi Arabia. The status quo is unsustainable. And this is way beyond the scope of Imran's capabilities. The PMO office in Pakistan has a hard enough time dealing with internal villains. But in a 10-year timeframe I hope he does play a role here, a role there to bring about a fruitful outcome.
- Law and order inside Pakistan. This means unless you are a soldier or a police officer, you don't get to carry a gun inside Pakistan. Zero tolerance for terrorist groups. He really has to lead the Pakistani army here. When Imran's hero and role model Nitish Kumar came to power in Bihar in 2005, he only said, "Law and order!" That is all he said when he ran for office, and that is all he worked on for the first few years. Nitish knew that unless he could restore law and order, nothing else he does really matters. Next thing you know, he had put 70,000 people behind bars.
- Infrastructure. That road that China is building is key. It will transform Pakistan. It will unify Pakistan. I am for robust federalism in Pakistan. I am not for breaking Pakistan into smaller pieces, a fantasy of some Hindu fanatics in India. After law and order, Nitish focused on building roads. Roads, roads and more roads. When Deng Xiaoping started his reforms in China, his first mantra was, lay down train tracks everywhere. Infrastructure is important.
- Health and education. This is another place where Bill and Melinda Gates are huge fans of Nitish Kumar. I believe Imran Khan is making all the right noise here and making the right moves. I wish him all the best.
- 5G. This is where you want to take your bathroom trip when Donald Trump starts talking about Huawei. If the Chinese want to steal Pakistani secrets, let them. That might be a stealth way of forcing them to learn Urdu. But get 5G done. And Huawei has the best deal in the market by a wide margin. Blanket Pakistan with 5G. This is more important than train tracks and roads and bridges. 5G is the most important infrastructure today. If you blanket the land with 5G, you will be able to do in 10-15 years, what China did in 30.
- Ease of Doing Business. Here, learn from Modi. The guy has helped India climb up the ranks.
Imran Wants To Lift 100 Million Pakistanis Out Of Poverty https://t.co/5Wv5B026dL @ImranKhanPTI @PTIofficial @PTIKPOfficial @PTICPOfficial @PTIPeshawar @SMQureshiPTI @ImranIsmailPTI @AliHZaidiPTI @PTIHazara @narendramodi @PMOIndia @BJP4India @AmitShah @MehboobaMufti @OmarAbdullah— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 23, 2019
Pakistan's prime minister blames Trump tweet for derailing Afghanistan peace deal https://t.co/u2UkRDxIHd
— Bloomberg (@business) September 24, 2019
Greta Thunberg For Nobel Peace Prize
“You say...that you understand the urgency, but no matter how sad and angry I am, I do not want to believe that, because if you really understood the situation and still kept on failing to act, then you would be evil, and that I refuse to believe.” pic.twitter.com/SA06P4bXZ7
— Justice Democrats (@justicedems) September 23, 2019
Greta Thunberg For Nobel Peace Prize https://t.co/c0UQvvFdVO @GretaThunberg @algore @BarackObama @Malala #ClimateChange #ClimateActionSummit #ShutDownDC #GreenNewDeal
— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 23, 2019
Everyone is like "Give Greta Thurnberg the Nobel Peace Prize!" but idk it seems like she would settle for an earth that doesn't burst into flames when she turns 40
— Julia Claire (@ohJuliatweets) September 23, 2019
Hong Kong: The Power Lies In Non-Violence
The movement is being called leaderless. But there is as much order and organization to the movement as there is in a crowdfunding campaign on Kickstarter. There is purpose. There is defiance. There is thought. There is discussion. There is mission. There is action.
Hong Kong leads. I don't see Hong Kong clamoring for what others have but they don't. I see Hong Kong leading. I see Hong Kong demanding for what other big cities don't have either. Hong Kong leads New York. Hong Kong leads DC. Maybe this is how Washington DC will gain statehood and due representation. Maybe this is how residents of New York City will gain voting rights. 40% of New Yorkers do not get to vote in the city elections.
Hong Kong leads the way.
Bu the method is important. Non-violence is the only good option. Not because the Hong Kong protestors are weak, but because that is how they keep their moral high ground.
The entire world is watching in real time.
The Hong Kong protests should become better organized politically. There is need for political conversations. Options have to be explored. If a near total shutdown of the city is not working, maybe a total shutdown has to be attempted. Because the current protests can not go on forever.
And the nuclear option is organizing for independence. I hope things don't go that far. But Beijing might not budge otherwise.
It is best that the five demands are met and one country, two systems is maintained. That is what is best for Hong Kong. That is what is best for the Chinese mainland, and the cause of democracy there.
But organizing for independence will take greater political sophistication. Millions of Hong Kongers will have to become active members of political parties. Leaders will have to emerge. Political strategies will have to be discussed.
Organizing protests does require conversations and strategies. But organizing for independence is a whole another level. Right now that political organization is lacking. Unless Beijing feels it might lose Hong Kong altogether, it might not budge. So that threat has to be created.
The world stands by Hong Kong. If Beijing attempts military action in Hong Kong, the world will shut down the Chinese economy. Chinese exports will come down dramatically. Beijing knows that to be the case. And so a credible threat for independence has to be created. That is the only way Beijing will come around to accepting the five demands. Hong Kong deserves nothing less.
The police have to be investigated. Only an independent commission could do that. The Chief Executive of Hong Kong has to be directly elected. It is going to be one of the leaders of the movement. All members of the Hong Kong Legislature need to be directly elected by Hong Kong citizens. A vast majority of them are going to be those who are currently part of the movement.
That is the way forward. The earlier Beijing makes peace with that, the better.
One country, two systems. Really.
“You say...that you understand the urgency, but no matter how sad and angry I am, I do not want to believe that, because if you really understood the situation and still kept on failing to act, then you would be evil, and that I refuse to believe.” pic.twitter.com/SA06P4bXZ7
— Justice Democrats (@justicedems) September 23, 2019
Young Progressives Making Mistakes
Capitalism's Own Propaganda Machine
How Will Democracy Come To The Arab Countries?
Kashmir: Not Normal Yet
Trying To Understand Hong Kong And China
News: Hong Kong, Kashmir, Vigilantism, Curfew, Terrorism, Diaspora
Hong Kong, Non Violence Works
Globalization 4.0
News: Hong Kong, Vancouver, Diaspora Nationalism
News: Hong Kong, October 1, Protest Slang, Mental Conditioning
Xi Jinping Should Act
The Asymmetry Between Beijing And Hong Kong Is On Hong Kong's Side
Defiant Hong Kong
Microsft, Huawei, Trump, 5G
The Two Wangs
Hong Kong: Antennae Problem?
Hong Kong: No Police Solution, No Military Solution, Only A Political Solution
Hong Kong: Let The Dragon Grow Up
Navigating The Hong Kong Protests
UN human rights experts express concern about excessive use of force in Hong Kong protests https://t.co/oqaD1bPv1z
— Hong Kong Watch (@hk_watch) September 11, 2019
Bar Human Rights Committee of England and Wales speaking out about the need for an independent inquiry https://t.co/9OaG5xsrh2
— Hong Kong Watch (@hk_watch) September 13, 2019
BHRC issues statement raising serious concern about response by #HongKong authorities to ongoing protests, including credible reports of police brutality, violence against & mass arrests of protestors, & HK gov't failure to order a full/transparent inquiry https://t.co/LBmq8pExf9 pic.twitter.com/r6FTe3XfNh
— BHRC (@BarHumanRights) September 13, 2019
Great to see momentum building behind the Human Rights and Democracy Act at the @CECCgov hearing. Time for it to be passed. https://t.co/46hrgjvyrb
— Hong Kong Watch (@hk_watch) September 18, 2019
Chris Patten: China must give Hong Kong leaders the space to compromise.https://t.co/Xf4b62Q18V
— Hong Kong Watch (@hk_watch) September 19, 2019
This is a major positive step forward https://t.co/E0Jvm6yurl
— Hong Kong Watch (@hk_watch) September 19, 2019
Amnesty looked into the conduct of the Hong Kong Police Force and we came back with a clear conclusion:
— Nicholas Bequelin 林偉 (@bequelin) September 19, 2019
The Independent Police Complaints Council (ICCP) is totally unfit to address police misconduct.
It is urgent to set up an independent and impartial investigation. https://t.co/Yt1E43EuaN
Amnesty accuses Hong Kong police of abuses, torture of protesters https://t.co/HiHnnWfu0f pic.twitter.com/AZPyMbjUDo
— Reuters Top News (@Reuters) September 20, 2019
Hong Kong: The Power Lies In Non-Violence https://t.co/EbrWkaUfVl @demosisto @joshuawongcf @nathanlawkc @maryhui @kinlinglo @sumlokkei @rachel_cheung1 @lokinhei @HKDemocrats @WilsonLeungWS @HongKongPLG@jasonyng @BillyOYLi @cng1238 @Fight4HongKong #HongKong #HongKongProtests
— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 23, 2019
Hong Kong: The Power Lies In Non-Violence https://t.co/EbrWkaUfVl @FreedomHKG @BeWaterHKG @ezracheungtoto @antd @RichScotford @XinqiSu @holmeschan_ @chowtingagnes @ray_slowbeat @hk_watch @hkpoliceforce @EricCheungwc @hoccgoomusic #HongKong #HongKongProtests #hongkongpolice
— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 23, 2019
Hong Kong: The Power Lies In Non-Violence https://t.co/EbrWkaUfVl @lokinhei @kevinkfyam @hkjohnsonyeung @AmnestyHK @HKWORLDCITY @missy_lao @elson_tong @hkchrislau @alexhofford @alexhofford @GlobalSolidHK @antd @BillyOYLi @hk_watch @bequelin #HongKong #HongKongPolice
— Paramendra Kumar Bhagat (@paramendra) September 23, 2019